Yes, they are tracking you through your cell phone

A federal court ruling has revealed that the U.S. Department of Justice has routinely been monitoring the locations of people through their cell phones, without probable cause, and in secret.

Your shiny new GPS-enabled cell phone can be used to track you in real time by government authorities, even when you supposedly have it disabled. The only way to prevent it is to shut the phone off, which makes it not very useful.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation argued in federal court, in the first such case to actually have opposition show up, that the Fourth Amendment requires a search warrant for such surveillance.

The government has tried to justify this gross expansion of its authority by combining two surveillance statutes, neither of which authorize cell phone tracking on their own. As EFF explains in its brief, there is no support anywhere for this argument — not in the statutes’ language, nor in legislative history, case law, or academic commentary. Indeed, it contradicts the government’s own electronic evidence manual. “It’s as if the government wants the court to believe that zero plus zero somehow equals one,” said [staff attorney Kevin] Bankston. — Electronic Frontier Foundation

EFF further states that the federal court ruling indicates that prior authorizations were granted by the courts without the prosecution even establishing probable cause to believe that a crime has been or will be committed, a critical legal standard under U.S. law.

It’s partly because of things like this that I’ve had my phone off for most of the last week, only turning it on to check messages or make a call. Not that I’m a criminal, far from it. But the government has no right or reason to track me in real time. If they are only using this power against criminals, then showing probable cause in court in order to get a warrant should be easy enough. Otherwise, anybody could be tracked at any time for any reason — or no reason at all. And America should not be that sort of police state.

7 Responses to Yes, they are tracking you through your cell phone


4 Trackbacks & Pingbacks »»

  1. Pingback by Cell phone tracking “perverse,” “misleading,” “contrived,” “unsupported” by law – Phone Watch | 2005/10/28 at 16:21:56
  2. Pingback by The news just keeps breaking – IO ERROR | 2005/11/10 at 11:35:59
  3. Pingback by Law enforcement to track everyone via every method without oversight – Homeland Security or Homeland Stupidity | 2006/01/01 at 00:08:03
  4. Pingback by All Writs Act: Writs of surveillance or writs of assistance? – Homeland Security or Homeland Stupidity | 2006/01/01 at 00:42:02

3 Comments

  1. Comment by therese scott | 2006/01/22 at 15:05:12

    We recieve junk faxes daily (and often at 2qm), to which I respond with a call to ATT with the offenders number garnered thru the miracle of caller ID only to find there is no way to stop the @##$&les because they have every legal right to use a phone # that only sends but cannot recieve and even the BBB can’t do anything about their behavior? Our legal system no longer protects the people for whom it was created; it now only serves to protect faceless business from the hapless citizens of our blosseming police state. Pity George Orwell was right…

  2. I really have no idea what junk faxes have to do with tracking cell phones, but there are things you can do about them and I’ll try to address this in the near future, weather permitting.

  3. Comment by GMAN | 2006/06/25 at 05:10:39

    Welcome to America….if you don’t like our national security policies…LEAVE! We are in a time of War and the government should have every tool including GPS tracking to ensure our national safety.

Bad Behavior has blocked 140 access attempts in the last 7 days.